What Makes Data Centers So Special?

Amazon data center under construction Monday, Nov. 9, 2026, in New Florence, Mo. (AP Photo / Jeff Roberson)

The discourse around data centers has exploded over the past year, taking center stage as a political issue — and one of the few that Americans hold similar views on across party lines. From The New York Times’ “The Data Center Boom” to The Atlantic’s coverage of “The Data Center Rebellion,” almost every major publication now has extensive commentary on data center proliferation and the costs they impose on local communities. The Wall Street Journal has a whole topic page dedicated to data centers. But data centers have been around for decades, with the first large-scale center being traced back to Oregon in 2006. So what makes data centers universally unpopular, and why are we only paying attention now?

Data centers propose a common infrastructural dilemma: their national economic prospects are promising, but they impose concentrated costs for local communities. A single hyperscale data center can consume around 100 to 1,000 megawatts of electricity, equivalent to that of a small to mid-sized city. Their constant 24-hour electricity demand complicates reliance on renewable energy sources like solar and wind, which depend on weather conditions. Data centers also require massive amounts of water for cooling and temperature maintenance, reaching highs of 5 million gallons every day. These facilities contribute to air pollution, noise pollution, electricity blackouts, and utility costs in their local vicinity. As a result, their development raises concerns about a myriad of health risks, including cardiovascular diseases, waterborne illnesses, cognitive stress, and temperature-related illness.

These costs are undeniable, but what makes data centers such a focal point of national scrutiny? Aside from their rapid development and media proliferation, there are a few major distinctions between large-scale data centers (often referred to as “hyperscale” centers), and other comparable industrial facilities. For one, data centers provide markedly fewer long-term employment opportunities. A $500 million data center employs just around 50 long-term workers, compared to approximately 2,000 at an automobile manufacturing facility of equivalent investment. Data centers have been linked to downstream economic benefits for some counties, increasing overall employment by 3.5 percent and wages by 5 percent. However, these benefits only appear statistically significant for centers placed in metropolitan areas, and the wage increase is likely inflated due to a small concentration of high-paying IT positions. Data centers also appear to have diminishing marginal returns for communities. Given that the majority of data center expansion occurs in clusters, communities may be faced with mounting costs and few economic returns.

The growing scrutiny of data centers has translated into a massive political and social backlash. Data centers became a primary issue in the 2026 midterm elections, serving as key talking points for candidates across the political spectrum, from Republican Sen. Josh Hawley to progressive senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed. This sentiment appears to be capturing Americans across demographic lines. Pew research demonstrates that 90 percent of Americans now say they know about data centers, and 60 percent of Americans are uncomfortable with the prospect of a new data center in their local community — numbers that have increased substantially in 2026 alone. These developments come with the growing presence of data centers across the country, increasing from 609 to 1,283 in the past six years. But this expansion pales when compared to the 3,230 new centers that are either planned or under construction as of 2026. 

While the AI boom and the growing necessity for data centers is a global phenomenon, the broad public disapproval and scale of investment present a uniquely intense contradiction in the United States. Of the over 30 countries surveyed in Stanford’s 2026 AI Index Report, the US consistently ranks the lowest in terms of trust in government regulation of AI and optimism toward AI’s impact on the economy or public policy. Simultaneously, the US hosts more than ten times the number of data centers as the next leading nation, and invested $285.9 billion into AI infrastructure from the private sector — more than 23 times as much as China.

Data centers appear to be a growing threat to the local resources and health of communities across the nation, with limited economic returns for local residents. Despite mounting skepticism and disapproval, the industry sees unprecedented expansion and investment. So, is there any hope for meaningful representation and safeguards on these issues, or are Americans right to be pessimistic about the future of data centers and AI expansion?

Political action and organization are beginning to take root beyond public rhetoric. Sixteen states are considering banning data center development to protect communities, while demonstrations protesting data center development have taken place across 75 separate facilities. In addition to public policy and political demonstrations, there are a growing number of lawsuits against data centers. For example, Amazon Data Services paid $20.5 million to settle a class-action lawsuit alleging groundwater pollution in Oregon, and there are an additional 20 data center-related cases in active litigation across the country.

The future of data centers in the US is uncertain, but it is clear that community concerns have finally gained momentum. Just as the presence of data centers has rapidly expanded, so has awareness and prioritization of public opinion. Because data center construction is a local infrastructure issue, local political participation is particularly influential. Through local elections, public hearings, and national conversation, we have the power to demand meaningful safeguards and protect our communities.

The Zeitgeist aims to publish ideas worth discussing. The views presented are solely those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editorial board.