What Makes a Successful Woman in Trump’s White House?

Former White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt speaks at the Republican convention, Thursday, Sept. 10, 2026, in Dallas. (AP Photo / Jacquelyn Martin)

What does it take for a woman to succeed in President Trump’s White House? Loyalty? Experience? Bleached hair? The ability to defend the President regardless of the truth? For Karoline Leavitt, Katie Zacharia, and Susie Wiles, the answers seem to vary. 

Leavitt left her position as White House Press Secretary to focus on her family; Trump publicly endorsed the decision and referred to her as an “outside advisor”. She has accepted a position as a political commentator on Fox News. Despite blatantly lying numerous times, Leavitt was an excellent communicator and handled every shot fired at her with grit and grace. Following her resignation, Trump replaced Leavitt with Katie Zacharia. Unlike Leavitt, Zacharia delivered a flaming dumpster-fire performance at her first briefing and was criticized by the masses for her lack of professionalism and public speaking skills. She was fired less than a week after the joke of a press briefing.

Then came Wiles, a seasoned political strategist who operated as the president’s White House Chief of Staff. She was a major player in orchestrating Trump’s electoral victory in 2024 –– only to be replaced by a man following the Republicans’ significant midterm election losses. 

These three women had very different political careers and departures that raise the same question: what actually determines success for the women in Trump’s administration? 

Karoline Leavitt’s tenure as White House Press Secretary raises the question of whether being an effective communicator and being truthful one are mutually exclusive. Despite repeatedly facing criticism for making untruthful, misleading, or controversial statements, Leavitt remained a confident and composed spokesperson. One example was when Leavitt falsely claimed that Trump’s “One Big Beautiful Bill” would not increase the federal deficit despite independent analyses projecting the bill would add trillions of dollars to the debt over the following decade. Her ability to unconditionally defend the president’s actions, even when his administration’s claims were directly contradicted by evidence, may be Leavitt’s defining political strength. When Leavitt decided to resign to focus on her family, Trump publicly supported her decision and referred to her as “one of the best White House Press Secretaries in the History of the Office.” Unlike many other officials who leave the Trump administration under less peaceful conditions, Leavitt departed with his approval and, according to Trump, remains one of his top advisors. Her experience forces the question of whether success in the Trump Administration is measured by a spokesperson’s commitment to transparency or by their unwavering loyalty to the president. 

Unlike her predecessor, Katie Zacharia’s reign as White House Press Secretary was short-lived and contentious from the start. Her first briefing lasted just ten minutes, during which she failed to communicate effectively –– only answering questions from three news outlets. However, the circumstances surrounding her preparation and experience raise questions about whether she was set up to fail. According to Zacharia, she received her final briefing materials just two hours before facing the national media. While her performance (and her lying about being a lawyer) warranted criticism, the administration must also bear the responsibility for placing her in a highly demanding position without adequately preparing her. Her quick dismissal left me debating who should bear the blame for this disaster. 

Leavvit and Zacharia experienced vastly different outcomes despite holding the same position. Leavitt’s ability to defend the Trump Administration, even when its claims were undeniably false, earned her Trump’s continued support. Zacharia, who displayed similar loyalty to the president (but definitely not to Leavitt’s extent), struggled to project the same authority and was quickly dismissed. Their experiences suggest that Trump’s White House does not depend solely on loyalty, but on how unconditionally and convincingly that loyalty is displayed. Yet even women with political experience and proven loyalty are not guaranteed job security in Trump’s White House, as Susie Wiles’s recent departure demonstrates. 

Susie Wiles, a seasoned political strategist, was recently replaced as White House Chief of Staff following the GOP’s midterm loss, despite helping secure Trump’s 2024 presidential victory. Trump reportedly blamed Wiles for the election results, despite her previous success and otherwise good reputation within the Trump administration. Her departure is a prime instance of whether political accomplishments matter when the president is looking for someone to blame. 

Together, these three separate departures that happened in such a short time raise the broader question about the treatment of women in Trump’s White House. In its article “The Scapegals,” The Atlantic examines a pattern of women losing prominent positions within the administration, suggesting that they have become convenient scapegoats for Trump’s political failures. Leavitt, Zacharia, and Wiles faced varying circumstances, but their collective experiences highlight how Trump evaluates women’s competence and loyalty and how quickly his approval can change. While there is nothing directly tied to their departures that proves gender discrimination, there is one constant factor among these recent staff changes –– which leads me to question if these women are held to different standards of accountability than their male counterparts. 

To be clear, I am not claiming that these dismissals can be solely attributed to gender. Zacharia faced legitimate criticisms regarding her performance, while Wiles’s departure followed major electoral losses. In fact, Trump had already discussed plans for personnel changes following the midterms. However, acknowledging these circumstances does not eliminate the possibility of gendered expectations. The question is not whether every woman who leaves the administration is a victim of sexism, but whether these women face the same standards of accountability as their male peers. 

Ultimately, the experiences of these three women suggest that success in Trump’s White House is less dependent on a consistent standard of competence than on staying on the president’s good side. Leavitt’s loyalty earned her praise, Zacharia’s briefing disaster led to dismissal, and Wiles’s political accomplishments could not shield her from blame. These contrasting experiences show that success has never been defined by what these women have achieved for the administration, but rather by whether the president views them as politically useful.

The Zeitgeist aims to publish ideas worth discussing. The views presented are solely those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the views of the editorial board.